How one family’s DCF case turned into a national story and brought a federal investigation to a small Mass. school district
This story originally ran in the Boston Globe, Sept. 24, 2026. With Aidan Ryan.
A Southborough couple’s fight with Massachusetts to regain custody of their child, and block the teen’s gender transition, has stewed for nearly two years.
It only took days, though, for Joseph and Arlene Kutzko’s story on a Fox News-produced podcast to blaze through social media and conservative news outlets and prompt a federal investigation of a small Massachusetts school district. They are now the latest figures in a nationwide fight over schools’ gender identity policies.
The Kutzkos’ lawyer, Vernadette Broyles, a former Massachusetts resident with a bachelor’s degree from Yale and a law degree from Harvard, is among the country’s most prominent voices on the issue, working in court and with legislators to bar schools from adopting students’ name and pronoun preferences without parental permission. With the midterms approaching, transgender identity has become a talking point for Republicans trying to win over voters on an issue that has divided the left.
“[Conservatives] have been extraordinarily good at finding small, edge cases, and then exploiting them to make it sound like schools across America are transitioning kids without parents’ knowledge,” said Lanae Erickson, senior vice president for social policy, education, and politics at Third Way, a center-left think tank. Erickson added that politicians on the left have struggled to respond.
Broyles, who described gender-transitioning medical treatments for children as child abuse, according to a 2023 Mother Jones article, said the couple’s decision to go public now had no connection to the impending midterms but was instead connected to their child’s case as it moves through the family court system.
Documents shared by the Kutzkos and criminal court records outline the following narrative about the family’s case.
Officials at the child’s former school, Northborough’s Algonquin Regional High School, contacted police in January 2025 to report allegations Joseph Kutzko struck and threatened his child. Arlene Kutzko was later charged with witness intimidation after texting her child about the allegations. Charges against both parents were resolved without an admission of guilt in December 2025.
Joseph Kutzko’s arrest prompted an investigation by the state Department of Children and Families. The child welfare agency did not support a finding of physical abuse, but did conclude both parents had been negligent. It is unclear when the teen was removed from the home or why.
The Kutzkos allege school officials at Algonquin undermined their Catholic faith when they “secretly transitioned” the then-15-year-old’s gender through counseling sessions. DCF took the Kutzkos’ child, they claimed, because they opposed a gender identity switch. They say they have never gotten an explanation of why DCF supported a finding of neglect against them.
The case came to a head this month, said Broyles, because DCF supported a plan to provide the child, now 17, with hormone treatments. State law permits parents of children in state custody to challenge such a plan in court. A judge has paused the DCF plan and the next hearing is scheduled for late October.
Algonquin school officials have said a disagreement between parents and a student over gender identity would not prompt a call to police or DCF.
Massachusetts doesn’t have a statewide policy dictating how schools should treat transgender students, but state guidelines that date back to 2012 recommend schools should consider students’ wishes on when and with whom to discuss their gender transition.
Broyles declined to say when and how she connected with the Kutzkos, citing attorney-client privilege. During the parents’ Sept. 13 podcast appearance, the host, Lauren Green, noted she learned of their story from Broyles. (In May 2025, Broyles appeared on the same podcast, where she spoke about “the transgender trend,” saying the “phenomenon is a wholesale assault on the biblical worldview, on biological reality, on truth itself.”)
It’s not clear exactly how or when the Trump administration decided to open an investigation into the child’s former school district, the Public Schools of Northborough and Southborough. But the Department of Education press release includes details from the podcast interview.
“Fox is increasingly playing a role in identifying ‘social problems’ that the Trump administration already has a concern with,” said A.J. Bauer, an assistant professor of journalism at the University of Alabama who studies conservative news. “You can think about Fox right now as almost like a shot caller.”
Broyles’s Georgia law firm, Child & Parental Rights Campaign, takes on cases that seek to change school policies for gender nonconforming youth and has filed briefs in support of several others.
In 2022, a group of parents sued the Ludlow School Committee over a policy that bars educators from divulging to parents a student’s decision to choose their own name or pronouns without that student’s consent. CPRC, as a co-counsel representing the families in their appeal to the First Circuit Court of Appeals, argued the policy violated parents’ right to direct their children’s upbringing and medical care. The court sided with the school committee. The parents appealed to the Supreme Court, but the high court declined to hear the case.
The firm is supported largely by Christian charitable groups and a few very large donations from funds that are permitted to keep their donors opaque. More than half of its $969,000 in revenue in 2024, the most current year reported, came from two individual grants given anonymously through large charitable and donor-advised funds.
One was DonorsTrust Inc., one of the nation’s largest dark money contributors to conservative causes. It gave $300,000 to the law firm in 2023 and 2024. One of DonorsTrust’s largest single grants in 2024, more than $20 million, went to America First Legal Foundation, a conservative public interest organization founded by the prominent Trump adviser Stephen Miller.
Broyles did not respond to a question about the grant through DonorsTrust.
The Education Department’s investigation of the Massachusetts school district, announced on Sept. 17, is only the latest to push back on school gender identity policies, which federal authorities say violate parents’ rights. Similar investigations involving the Education Department and, in some cases, the Department of Justice, have cropped up against at least seven school districts and three state education departments since 2025. The federal agencies cite several laws as the basis for the investigations, including those that require schools to disclose students’ education records to parents and obtain parents’ consent to certain evaluations, such as mental health and sexual behavior.
The administration’s campaign to challenge school policies is an abuse of power, said Chris Erchull, senior staff attorney at GLBTQ Legal Advocates & Defenders, a national law firm with a focus on New England.
Schools are supposed to provide safe environments for students, and respecting their preferred identity is an extension of that mission, he said. While he acknowledged a student could in rare cases be at risk from a parent who disapproves of gender transitioning, the guidelines reflect a larger philosophy that it’s not educators’ role to record and report everything a student says to parents.
“The right path for schools to take is to encourage and support students to have conversations at home, without school interfering in that conversation,” he said.
Broyles, the Kutzkos’s lawyer, said schools and state agencies simply should not be able to substitute their judgment for parents’. They are, in effect, concluding parental “unsafety and unfitness” without any due process, she said.
Broyles’s strategy appears to be to bring one of her cases before the Supreme Court to set a precedent saying a school cannot withhold a student’s gender identity from parents.
The Supreme Court has so far declined to rule on the underlying legal questions. But a recent, narrow high court ruling in a California case signaled that things might be changing. In it, the court stated that the parents’ arguments — that California policies barring teachers from notifying parents of a student’s gender transition without the student’s consent interfere with their rights to raise children in accordance with their faith — are likely to succeed.
It’s a statement that gives Broyles hope.
“There is a shift toward a common recognition, across the political spectrum, that school officials cannot supplant parents for these kinds of weighty, medical, sociological, religious, moral, spiritual decisions,” she said.