There’s a pattern of child sexual abuse at Mass. group homes and experts fear many cases go unreported

This story originally ran in the Boston Globe, April 27, 2026.

At a state-licensed residential school for disabled children in Brewster, a vocational teacher raped a student repeatedly, including once at the teacher’s home.

At a facility in Pittsfield, a worker discussed having sex with a teenager after the resident turned 18 amid a pattern of grooming behavior. That youth wrote of the worker in a journal, “Don’t ever forget me! Remember our deal && plan when I’m 18.”

At a residential program for troubled youth in Stoughton, a mental health provider arranged hotel rendezvous for sex with a youth in their care — and brought the teen alcohol and $1,000 in money and gifts.

Over a three-year span, from August 2022 through August 2025, state officials identified 20 instances of workers engaging in sexual misconduct with children and young adults who were or had been in their care, according to a Globe review of state records. The incidents included sexual comments, inappropriate touching, grooming, and rape. Throughout most of that period, investigators identified credible accounts of child sexual mistreatment almost once every six weeks.

The Office of the Child Advocate, which keeps its own tally of sex abuse incidents in congregate care settings by fiscal year, reported similar numbers of incidents annually.

The cases identified by the Globe are likely a mere hint of the frequency of child and youth sexual mistreatment in residential facilities, where some cases cannot be confirmed, and many more are never reported, experts said. One recent study estimated that more than a quarter of children in group homes are sexually abused either by staff or other residents.

“When you create a system where you take some of the most vulnerable children one can imagine, put them all together in one place, that is going to attract predators,” said Richard Wexler, executive director of the National Coalition For Child Protection Reform, which focuses on reforming the child welfare system.

Nearly 5,300 children and youth live in 311 residential facilities licensed by the state. Among them are children with addiction or behavioral health challenges, learning disabilities, and many are involved in the youth detention or child welfare systems. Among the licensed residences are about 130 group homes where the state places many children deemed at risk if left with their own families, who may have already inflicted on them physical or sexual abuse.

Massachusetts’s child welfare system places kids in group homes at a rate that exceeds the national average.

“Those kids have a red target on their backs,” said Jetta Bernier, head of Enough Abuse, a child safety organization. “They don’t understand boundaries. Their self-esteem is so violated they become easy victims.”

Additional abuse at a supposedly safe facility puts their recovery even farther out of reach. “It’s kind of the straw that makes everything completely devastating,” said David Finkelhor, a University of New Hampshire professor and director of the Crimes against Children Research Center.

In Massachusetts, children’s vulnerability to abuse is compounded by poor staff training, lax oversight of homes, and laws that fail to criminally punish workers who engage in sexual relations with children 16 and older. The Globe’s findings come as state officials debate significant regulatory reform to group homes and others call for eliminating them altogether.

In some cases, the sex abuse cases reviewed by the Globe could likely have been prevented.

In 10 instances, staff either ignored or minimized warning signs and red flags about a worker who went on to mistreat a child, or didn’t follow procedures that could have prevented or stopped abuse.

One state report documented a worker who was chastised 18 times starting in August 2021, including six times for inappropriate behavior with residents, and received three “final written warnings,” within three months. That worker wasn’t fired until February 2023, after credible allegations emerged that they made sexual comments to residents, showered with a youth while wearing a bathing suit, and appeared naked in front of kids.

The operator of that home, RFK Alliance, declined to comment.

At another home, Lexington’s Pelham Academy, operated by the Justice Resource Institute, residents who complained about a worker with a “pattern of personal boundary and conduct concerns” were told to stop gossiping and were punished.

“JRI’s staff are trained on how student complaints are received, reviewed, and we continue to reinforce these procedures,” said Holly Mazelli, a spokesperson for JRI.

Lax penalties for some offenders also contribute to abuse, experts said.

A quirk in state law permits adults in positions of authority to have consensual sex with teenagers in their care if the youth is 16 or older. These incidents may get a worker fired and prompt a DCF finding of abuse, but won’t put them in prison, despite the lopsided power dynamics and potential for exploitation.

At least four reports reviewed by the Globe involved youth over the age of consent. A 2025 incident at Pelham Academy involved a sexual relationship between a young resident and a childcare counselor, the same person who spurred concerns in other children that workers dismissed. The resident involved had turned 16, and the state report described the worker and youth researching Massachusetts’ age of consent before they “knew they were OK” to have sex.

A bill under consideration in the state Legislature would criminalize such relationships for workers in schools, but does not apply to workers at residential facilities. An earlier iteration of the bill sponsored by state Representative Leigh Davis, a Democrat from Great Barrington, had included group home workers.

“We need to start somewhere, and if this is where we’re starting, I’m fine with that,“ Davis said of the less-expansive bill.

Bernier, head of the Massachusetts child abuse prevention organization, has been pushing to close the age of consent loophole for a decade, she said. The mass of bills the state Legislature considers, and the taboo subject matter, have kept proposals from moving forward, she said.

“This is a topic a lot of people find distasteful,” she said. “They don’t want to talk about it.”

The Globe confirmed through state officials and court records that five former workers were charged in relation to sexual mistreatment from 2023 to 2024. Two have pleaded guilty to child rape.

Successful prosecutions are difficult. Incidents that don’t involve outright sexual assault require prosecutors to show a pattern and intent. It’s challenging, Bernier said, to distinguish for a jury whether an authority figure’s closeness with a child is due to a warm disposition or malicious intent.

Even when a rape has happened, physical evidence is rare, and victims may not come forward until well after the assaults took place, said Erica Brody, a Boston lawyer representing a girl repeatedly raped at a Springfield group home, the now-defunct Greylock, in 2023.

The perpetrator of those assaults, Xavier Cruz, pleaded guilty to child rape in March, but in other cases, accountability is elusive.

The girl, who asked not to be identified, filed a civil suit in December against the state and the group home operator, but such action is rare, Brody said. Many group home residents are in the custody of the state, which is unlikely to file civil action, she said.

“DCF would have to make a decision to sue itself,” Brody said.

Her client’s case is still being litigated.

In a statement to the Globe, the victim’s father said she experienced depression and anxiety in the wake of her abuse.

“What happened to her at Greylock was the worst thing that has happened in her life,” her father said. “She didn’t have anyone there to protect her, and she was just a vulnerable 14-year-old kid.”

The Office of the Child Advocate noted that the state attorney general is authorized to represent children who are victimized while in state care.

Officials with the state Department of Early Education and Care, the licenser of residential facilities, emphasize that they respond quickly and decisively when child sexual mistreatments or assaults are reported. Workers credibly accused of mistreating children were almost always fired, if they had not already left the programs. Their employers must document reforms in the wake of confirmed child mistreatment, and five facilities where incidents of child sexual mistreatment were substantiated are now shuttered.

This year, the department proposed a raft of regulatory changes designed to improve conditions at residential facilities. Those include a requirement that homes document a plan for identifying and reporting sexual abuse, grooming, and exploitation, and mandate training for workers on boundary awareness and identifying concerning behavior among colleagues. The new regulations could be approved next month.

“Our goal is to help create environments where both children and staff feel safe and can thrive,” said Amy Kershaw, EEC commissioner.

Experts who urge reform at residential facilities say there are additional ways to make them safer. Perpetrators of sexual abuse are often relatively close to the age of young residents. While some offenders are what Finkelhor, of UNH, called preferential pedophiles, many others are people predisposed to poor boundary maintenance, weak self-control, and a tendency to sexualize situations.

The latter group can be screened for through self-assessments or permissions that allow prior employers to disclose troubling incidents that wouldn’t show up in a background check.

“I think it’s controllable if you do a good job of vetting the people you hire, if you do a good job of training them,” Finkelhor said.

Maria Mossaides, the head of the state’s watchdog agency for children, the Office of the Child Advocate, said residential facilities need greater oversight, particularly on weekend and overnight shifts, when there are fewer workers on duty. DCF should play a greater oversight role, she said, by assigning staff to visit group homes more often to evaluate the facilities and build relationships with the children there.

DCF did not respond directly to Mossaides’ comments, but a spokesperson said the agency does have personnel who routinely visit group homes to ensure they’re meeting contractual requirements.

Many child advocates argue that residential facilities are a flawed model. Kids in group or institutional settings are less likely to graduate high school, have less opportunity to develop life skills and positive relationships, and often describe these facilities as akin to a prison, according to an Annie E. Casey Foundation study.

Congregate housing should be used only infrequently for brief stays, said Elizabeth Letourneau, director of Johns Hopkins University’s Moore Center for the Prevention of Child Sexual Abuse. Currently, children remain in DCF-contracted congregate care settings an average of three and a half years.

“When you are surrounded by children day in and day out, and these children have already been identified by society as other or lesser or perhaps subhuman, it brings out the worst in the adults around them,” Letourneau said.

Today, the girl victimized at the Springfield home still has scars from self-harming committed after her abuse. She experienced dramatic weight gain and loss and has flashbacks. Just seeing a car like the one her abuser drove still sparks a burst of anxiety, according to a victim statement read during Cruz’s sentencing.

“My child has completely changed,” said the girl’s father. “It impacts her relationship with me and everyone in her life: her family, her friends, and teachers.”