Social workers have quit DCF in droves, costing children stability and delaying family reunifications

This story originally ran in the Boston Globe, Nov. 19, 2024. With Scooty Nickerson.

Desperate to see her three young children last month, Maria Toscano sent increasingly pleading text messages to her caseworker at the Department of Children and Families.

“Good morning,” she texted on Oct. 17, according to screen shots Toscano shared with the Globe. “I am trying to get everything set for [a] visit please text me when you have it.”

Oct. 18: “I haven’t heard back from you regarding this week’s visit and I was really looking forward to seeing my children.”

Oct. 21: “I really miss my babies, so due to no visit last week we will have 2 hours this week, correct?”

Other texts followed through Oct. 24. In response, silence from the caseworker charged with arranging Toscano’s weekly visits with her children.

After more than a week without an answer, the 41-year-old mother visited the Worcester Department of Children and Families office. To her shock, she learned that the woman she had been texting was no longer working with her family. A new caseworker had been assigned, and no one had told Toscano. This would be her children’s sixth social worker in less than a year, she said.

She finally got a visit scheduled to see her children, ages 7, 6, and 4, on Oct. 29, according to the texts she shared.

Toscano’s angst isn’t unique. Turnover among caseworkers is a troubling norm in the child welfare system, according to parents, foster families, and union representatives. But the problem grew worse during the COVID-19 pandemic, when social workers quit the Massachusetts child protection agency in droves, leaving families in the lurch. From 2016 to 2020, around 290 social workers quit the agency every year, on average. Then in 2021 the numbers spiked, with over 500 workers quitting. DCF countered with retention and recruiting initiatives, but in more recent years, more than 400 workers quit each year.

The losses have taken a toll. DCF’s mission is to ensure the safety of children whose parents have credible claims of abuse or neglect against them, whether that means providing services for parents, temporarily removing children, or finding them a new permanent home. But caseworker instability undercuts that mission. High turnover rates are associated with less stable placements for children and more time in foster care, according to a 2023 report from the Casey Family Programs, a national child welfare foundation. Research in Illinois in 2018 indicated young children with more caseworkers were less likely to find a permanent home.

Eric Tennen, a Winthrop lawyer who has fostered children for five years, described his progress caring for a teenager as Sisyphean, with care plans virtually rebooting with each new social worker.

His foster daughter needs therapy, he said, and yet “no one’s gotten them a therapist. No one knows if they’re in school.”

He estimated the girl has had four caseworkers in less than two years, and new ones are often frighteningly unprepared. In August, he and his wife, Leah Tennen, scheduled a meeting with a caseworker temporarily assigned to the teen’s case. The worker had little understanding of the girl’s history and the meeting was largely unproductive, the couple said.

“We’re just sort of in limbo,” Leah Tennen said, “and so are these kids.”

Vicky Le Blanc, a foster parent from Spencer, estimated one child, who she eventually adopted, had 22 caseworkers in 4½ years. The lack of continuity, which has worsened since the pandemic, makes it nearly impossible to build the trust in adults that foster children need, said LeBlanc, who is quitting fostering after 16 years out of frustration.

“You finally get a good working relationship, and boom, that person’s gone, and you have to start all over again,” she said.

DCF’s social worker exodus appears less severe than that of other states, said Julie Collins, vice president of practice excellence at the Child Welfare League of America, a national charity that provides support for child welfare agencies. She said pandemic-era departures have been a national problem, with departures often driven by a desire for work that offered more money and less stress.

Still, DCF’s turnover rate of nearly 16 percent since 2021 exceeds a standard of no more than 12 percent recommended in the Casey Family Programs, report.

DCF has improved adoption rates since 2021, but other metrics show concerning trends. Since 2021, rates of family reunifications within 12 months worsened and the share of children with three or more placements in a year went up, according to the agency’s most recent annual report. And as a result of its high turnover rates, in 2023 DCF had its fewest number of caseworkers in seven years: 2,660.

DCF declined requests for an interview, and offered few insights into why so many workers left.

High turnover is “a perennial challenge,” DCF said in a statement. The agency offers social workers wellness support, training, and assistance preparing for a challenging licensing test that can force out many first-year staff members. Hiring incentives include field placements that contribute to master’s students’ degree requirements.

The agency noted reassignments can be a result of status changes in cases, such as when goals shift from family reunification to placement.

“People leave the department for a variety of personal and professional reasons,” said agency spokesperson Andrea Grossman. “We cannot speak to specific reasons people leave since circumstances vary.”

Union representatives offered more clarity. A significant number of social workers left DCF for less stressful, better-paying jobs in school districts, said Ethel Everett, the union’s chapter president for DCF. From 2019 to this May, Massachusetts schools added more than 2,000 new licensed support workers, including counselors, according to an analysis from Georgetown University’s Edunomics Lab in Washington, D.C.

Burnout accounts for many departures among younger workers, Everett said. And the reality of the job clashes with many new employees’ idealism.

“They think they’re going to be working with families, helping families to engage in services, to be self-sufficient, to move on to higher education,” Everett said. “The reality is we are moving kids night to night, we’re driving kids across the state for one-night placements to get them to school, we’re putting bandages on situations.”

In a vicious cycle that makes it harder to rebuild the workforce, high caseloads drive departures and worsen understaffing. DCF’s goal is an average of 15 cases per social worker, and as of 2021 it met that target. In 2022 and 2023, caseloads slightly exceeded DCF’s standards, according to the agency’s 2023 annual report, reaching 16.4 and 15.9 in 2022 and 2023, respectively.

A worker from DCF’s Chelsea office, who asked to not be named, left DCF in early 2024 after about two years, frustrated and disillusioned.

Related: In Massachusetts, cultural differences and limited resources can cost migrant families their children for a time

“They market that they’re here to help families, but some of the situations it just felt like I wasn’t,” he said.

At times, he said, he carried 25 cases at once. A turning point, he said, was a child removal he faced alone. He received no support as he confronted anguished parents and terrified children.

“You’re kind of in this moment of chaos and this moment of grief for a family, and you kind of need support at that moment,” he said. “It’s not the team atmosphere that was outlined to me.”

Toscano lost custody of her children in November 2023 due to signs she was being abused by her husband, who was also cited for substance abuse, according to DCF records she shared with the Globe. She was also cited for a history of violence and mental health concerns, though there is no allegation she was violent with her children.

Toscano has records of repeatedly enrolling in domestic violence counseling and therapy over the past year, yet the frequent changes in caseworkers leave her feeling like her benchmarks for success keep changing. This fall, DCF shifted her children’s goal from reunification to adoption, she said.

“I did all those things,” she said, “and my kids have not been reunified.”